1999
Danny Buckley
Frankfort, Ind. |
| 
2000
Randy Jones
Parker City, Ind. |
| 
2001
Jessica Bentley
Anderson, Ind. |
|
2003
Marushka Grogan
Indianapolis, Ind.
| 
2004
Lydia Umlauf
Rensselaer, Ind. | 
2005
Cailyn Alwine
Kendallville, Ind. |
2006
Travis Luke
Rensselaer, Ind.
| 
2007
Megan Fulkerson
Brownsburg, Ind.
| 
2008
Brooklyn Harney
Elwood, Ind. |