1999 (a)
Shayna Polomchak
Rensselaer, Ind. |
| 
1999 (b)
Hillary Armstrong
Wheatfield, Ind. |
| 
2000
Tyler Bentley
Anderson, Ind. |
2001
Camey Barbera
Batesville, Ind.
| 
2003
Taylor Hudelson
Delphi, Ind. | 
2004
Morganne Haas
Ferdinand, Ind. |
 2005
Emily Harm
Sunman, Ind.
| 
2006
Eli Schuler
North Manchester, Ind.
| 
2007
Abby Wilgenbusch
Sunman, Ind. |
2008
Adam Dills
Kendallville, Ind.
| 
2009
Sophie Chang
West Lafayette, Ind.
| 
2010
Heather Luo
West Lafayette, Ind.
|